《哈利·波特》电影未能纠正JK·罗琳在赫奇帕奇中的错误

239人浏览 / 0人评论

The Harry Potter Movies Failed To Fix JK Rowling's Hufflepuff Mistake (screenrant.com)

The Harry Potter Movies Failed To Fix JK Rowling's Hufflepuff Mistake

《哈利·波特》电影未能纠正JK·罗琳在赫奇帕奇中的错误

 

The Harry Potter movies failed to appreciate Hufflepuff for not only its positive traits, but also for the significant members of the Hogwarts house.

《哈利·波特》系列电影不仅没有欣赏赫奇帕奇的优点,也没有欣赏霍格沃茨学院的重要成员。

 

Similar to the books, the Harry Potter movies failed to fix one significant mistake regarding one of the Hogwarts' houses: Hufflepuff. Due to this house’s somewhat vague description and few named characters, it is often overshadowed by the other houses in J.K. Rowling's books. This has led to the misconception that Hufflepuff is an undesirable or even unimportant house despite it having some major effects on the storyline.

与原著相似,《哈利·波特》系列电影也未能弥补霍格沃茨学院的一个重大错误:赫奇帕奇。由于这个房子的描述有些模糊,很少有命名的角色,它经常被j·k·罗琳的书中其他房子的阴影。这导致了一种误解,认为赫奇帕奇是一个不受欢迎的,甚至是不重要的学院,尽管它对故事情节有一些重要的影响。

 

Among Harry Potter's four Hogwarts houses that students can be sorted into, Hufflepuff is the least easily defined. The other three houses, Gryffindor, Slytherin, and Ravenclaw, can all be described with one or two words. For example, students in Gryffindor are brave and noble while students in Slytherin are ambitious and manipulative and Ravenclaws are known for their intelligence and creativity. In contrast, Hufflepuff students cannot be summarized with a single word and are often simply labeled as “nice.” This has led to the common belief that Hufflepuff is the house for students who don't particularly stand out or excel in any way.

在《哈利·波特》中霍格沃茨的四个学院中,赫奇帕奇是最难界定的。另外三个学院,格兰芬多、斯莱特林和拉文克劳,都可以用一两个词来描述。例如,格兰芬多的学生是勇敢和高尚的,而斯莱特林的学生是雄心勃勃和控制欲强的,拉文克劳的学生以聪明和创造力著称。相反,赫奇帕奇的学生不能用一个词来概括,通常只是被贴上“好”的标签。这使得人们普遍认为赫奇帕奇学院是为那些在任何方面都不是特别突出或出类拔萃的学生开设的。

 

Sadly, the Harry Potter movies did little to challenge this idea or fix J.K. Rowling's oversight from the books barely including the Hufflepuff house and its characters. Based on this representation, or lack thereof, viewers who support Hufflepuff have had to research and add importance to the house on their own. The movies could have made this easier for viewers by placing a greater emphasis on Hufflepuff characters’ lives and impacts, but they often shortened or cut out these stories instead to reduce runtimes. However, it's a mistake, as Hufflepuff should be valued due to not only its positive traits but also for the significant characters who were members of the house.

遗憾的是,《哈利·波特》系列电影并没有挑战这个想法,也没有弥补J.K.罗琳对《赫奇帕奇》系列电影及其人物的忽视。基于这种表现,或者缺乏这种表现,支持赫奇帕奇的观众不得不自己研究并增加赫奇帕奇学院的重要性。电影本可以通过更多地强调赫奇帕奇角色的生活和影响,让观众更容易做到这一点,但他们经常缩短或删除这些故事,以减少运行时间。然而,这是一个错误,因为赫奇帕奇的价值不仅在于它积极的特点,还在于学院成员中有重要的人物。

 

Although Hufflepuff cannot be described as easily as the other houses, its members still possess many admirable traits. They are known for being kind, fair, loyal, and hardworking. Due to this, Hufflepuff has produced the fewest Dark wizards compared to the other Hogwarts houses, which is notable. In addition, Hufflepuff had the second-highest turnout of students for the Battle of Hogwarts (after Gryffindor), and none of them abandoned the fight.

尽管赫奇帕奇不像其他学院那样容易被描述,它的成员仍然有许多令人钦佩的特点。他们以善良、公平、忠诚和勤奋而闻名。正因为如此,赫奇帕奇是霍格沃茨培养黑巫师最少的学院,这一点值得注意。此外,赫奇帕奇的学生在霍格沃茨之战中是第二高的(仅次于格兰芬多),而且没有一个人放弃战斗。

 

Hufflepuff has also featured several prominent members who have had significant impacts on the Wizarding World. For example, Cedric Diggory was a skilled Hufflepuff student, prefect, and Quidditch captain who was chosen by the Goblet of Fire to represent Hogwarts in the Triwizard Tournament. Although he was ultimately killed by Peter Pettigrew at the end of the tournament, his spirit still helped save Harry by distracting Voldemort long enough for Harry to escape. In addition, Nymphadora Tonks was an Auror, a member of the second Order of the Phoenix, and a Metamorphmagus, meaning that she could change her appearance at will. Just after giving birth to her son, Teddy Remus Lupin, she fought and died in the Battle of Hogwarts.

赫奇帕奇还有几位杰出的成员,他们对魔法世界产生了重大影响。例如,塞德里克·迪戈里是赫奇帕奇学院的一名技艺高超的学生、级长和魁地奇队长,他被火焰杯选中代表霍格沃茨参加三强争霸赛。虽然他最终在争分赛结束时被小矮星彼得杀死,但他的灵魂仍然帮助拯救了哈利,因为他分散了伏地魔的注意力,让哈利得以逃脱。此外,尼法朵拉·唐克斯是一名傲罗,凤凰社的成员,也是一名易容马格斯,这意味着她可以随心所欲地改变自己的外表。在生下儿子特迪·莱姆斯·卢平之后,她参加了霍格沃茨战役,并在战斗中死去。

 

Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them also continued this thread of inspiring Hufflepuffs, revealing that Newt Scamander was a simple Magizoologist who became a major part in helping the side of good win the global wizarding war. Throughout this time, he fought against Gellert Grindelwald, one of the Wizarding World’s most dangerous Dark wizards, multiple times. While the Fantastic Beasts movies by necessity will include his Hufflepuff main character, Newt is already being sidelined in favor of focusing on a younger Albus Dumbledore. Both Fantastic Beasts and the Harry Potter movies could have explored Hufflepuff characters and their house far more.

《神奇动物在哪里》也延续了鼓舞赫奇帕奇学生的线索,揭示了纽特·斯卡曼德是一个简单的魔法动物学家,但他在帮助正义的一方赢得全球巫师战争中发挥了重要作用。在这段时间里,他与巫师界最危险的黑巫师之一盖勒特·格林德沃进行了多次战斗。虽然《神奇动物在何处》系列电影必然会包括他在赫奇帕奇的主角,但纽特已经被排除在主角之外,转而关注年轻的阿不思·邓布利多。《神奇动物在哪里》和《哈利波特》系列电影本可以更多地探索赫奇帕奇的角色和他们的家。

全部评论