《哈利·波特》:Reddit上关于金妮的10个不受欢迎的观点

208人浏览 / 0人评论 / 添加收藏

Harry Potter: 10 Unpopular Opinions About Ginny, According To Reddit (screenrant.com)

Harry Potter: 10 Unpopular Opinions About Ginny, According To Reddit

《哈利·波特》:Reddit上关于金妮的10个不受欢迎的观点

 

Ginny Weasley might be an important character by the end of the Harry Potter franchise, but fans on Reddit have controversial opinions about her.

金妮·韦斯莱可能会在《哈利·波特》系列电影的结尾成为一个重要的角色,但Reddit上的粉丝们对她的看法存在争议。

 

Ginny Weasley was known for many things in the Harry Potter franchise from being the youngest Weasley to opening the chamber of secrets, being a brilliant quidditch player, and becoming Harry's main love interest. Despite the minor and major changes in her life, she was relegated to the background, especially in the movies where most fans complain she was underdeveloped.

金妮·韦斯莱在《哈利·波特》系列电影中有很多出名的地方,从最年轻的韦斯莱到打开密室,是一名出色的魁地奇球员,并成为哈利的主要爱人。尽管在她的生活中有小有大的变化,她还是被降级为背景,尤其是在大多数粉丝抱怨她不好的电影中。

 

Her lack of development is just one of many things that fans discuss on Reddit. The platform has several controversial opinions about the youngest Weasley, both from the books and the movies. These range from her personality to her relationship with Harry, and her treatment of other characters, like Fleur Delacour.

她的发育不足只是粉丝们在Reddit上讨论的众多问题之一。平台上有几个关于最小的韦斯莱的有争议的观点,都来自书和电影。从她的性格到她与哈利的关系,以及她对其他角色的处理,比如芙蓉·德拉库尔。

 

10Ginny & Harry's Relationship Was Well Done In The Movies

10金妮和哈利在电影里的关系很好

 

Ginny and Harry's relationship started with her crush on him, which he barely noticed. They started dating in The Half-Blood Prince, and in the infamous Harry Potter epilogue they're married with kids. Reddit user commented that their relationship "was executed reasonably well and realistic."

金妮和哈利的关系始于她对他的迷恋,而他几乎没有注意到这一点。他们在《混血王子》中开始约会,在臭名昭著的《哈利波特》后记中,他们结婚并有了孩子。Reddit用户评论说,他们的关系“执行得相当逼真。”

 

Several fans disagree with this view of the couple's relationship as many believe it to have been severely underdeveloped in the movies. Ginny, herself, was hardly in the movies or around Harry enough to build up their relationship before they were suddenly together. Of course, with so many other characters in the show and so many plot lines to execute, it's understandable why there wasn't time to focus on the love story and the bare minimum was the best they could do.

一些粉丝不同意这种看法,因为许多人认为这对情侣的关系在电影中严重落后。金妮本人在电影里或在哈利身边几乎没有足够的时间来建立他们的关系,直到他们突然在一起。当然,剧中有这么多角色,这么多情节线要执行,这是可以理解的,为什么没有时间专注于爱情故事,他们能做的最好的最小限度。

 

9Ginny Isn't Well-Written

9金妮并不出彩

 

Some fans preferred Ginny from the books because she was more fleshed-out than her movie counterpart. However, the Redditor No_Risk_8848 commented that "she was an underdeveloped, poorly written character," even after reading the books.

一些粉丝更喜欢原著中的金妮,因为她比电影中的金妮更充实。然而,Reddit用户评论道:“她是一个欠充分的、写得很差的角色”,甚至在读完这些书之后。

 

Ginny seemed to change suddenly, from shy and quietly crushing on Harry to confident and badass. Granted, there wasn't much room to develop her, especially in the movies with so many other characters and storylines to focus on, but their relationship could have used a couple more moments together to establish their connection and build up their relationship.

金妮似乎突然变了,从安静地暗恋着哈利的害羞变成了自信的坏蛋。当然,她没有太多的发展空间,尤其是在有很多其他角色和故事情节需要关注的电影中,但他们的关系可以用更多的时间来建立他们的联系,建立他们的关系。

 

8Ginny Isn't A Likable Character

8金妮不是一个可爱的角色

 

There are many debates on Reddit on Ginny's character, with most arguing that she was better written in the books. The Reddittor JulianPouliot disagreed with this and said, "she's a bad imitation of Harry in some ways."

在Reddit上,关于金妮的角色有很多争论,大多数人认为她在书中写得更好。reddit用户朱利安·普利奥特(JulianPouliot)不同意这种说法,他说:“在某些方面,她跟哈利的模仿很糟糕。”

 

While they shared some similarities, some fans believed that in trying to create characters that would perfectly match each other, Ginny became a shadow of Harry with her sarcastic and aggressive nature that matches Harry's outspokenness and anger although Harry got a backstory and reasons for that, while Ginny didn't.

虽然他们有一些相似之处,但一些粉丝认为,在试图创造出完全匹配的角色时,金妮成为了哈利的影子,她讽刺和好斗的天性与哈利的直言不讳和愤怒相匹配,尽管哈利有一个背景故事和原因,而金妮没有。

 

7Harry Should Have Been With Luna Instead Of Ginny

7哈利应该和卢娜在一起而不是金妮

 

While some fans didn't agree with Harry and Ginny's pairing, he was commonly shipped with Hermione instead. A few fans shipped him with other characters from the movies and one of the rarest ones was Luna. The Reddit user PlatonicTroglodyte said the two of them "connected early (in the war) through understanding of parental loss."

虽然有些粉丝不同意哈利和金妮的组合,但他通常和赫敏一起出海。一些粉丝给他带来了电影中的其他角色,其中最罕见的一个是卢娜。Reddit用户PlatonicTroglodyte说,他们两人“很早就(在战争中)认识到失去父母的痛苦”。

 

Once they connected through that common loss, Harry was nice and civil to Luna when most people called her weird and she didn't treat him differently because of his celebrity status. Considering this, there is a little merit to the opinion that Harry and Luna could have been a good couple. In some ways, their friendship seemed more developed than Harry's relationship with Ginny.

当他们因为共同的失去而联系在一起时,当大多数人说卢娜古怪时,哈利对她很友好,彬彬有礼,而卢娜也没有因为他的名人身份而区别对待他。考虑到这一点,认为哈利和卢娜可能是一对好夫妻的观点也有一点可取之处。在某些方面,他们的友谊似乎比哈利和金妮的关系还要深厚。

 

6Cho Chang Was A Better Match For Harry Than Ginny

6秋·张比金妮更适合哈利

Before Harry and Ginny became a couple, he had a crush on Cho Chang and for a little while, it seemed like they would be together after Cedric's death. However, their relationship didn't really work out, but some fans felt like they would have been a better couple like the one Reddit user who said, "Cho Chang was a better love interest for Harry than Ginny Weasley."

在哈利和金妮成为一对之前,他曾暗恋过秋·张,有一段时间,他们似乎会在塞德里克死后在一起。然而,他们的恋情并没有走到最后,但一些粉丝觉得他们会成为更好的一对,就像Reddit用户说的:“秋·张比金妮·韦斯莱更适合哈利。”

 

Both relationships were actually similar, with one-sided crushes and very limited interactions, so it's likely Cho and Harry's relationship would have had the same lukewarm reception as the one he had with Ginny.

这两段关系其实很相似,都是单方面的迷恋,互动也非常有限,所以秋和哈利的关系很可能会像他和金妮的关系一样冷淡。

 

5Ginny Has A Better Relationship With Neville

5金妮和纳威的关系更好

 

While the major focus of the story was on the Golden Trio, the story occasionally cut to other characters like Ginny and Neville. The two of them actually had a good friendship and the Redditor SherdyRavers said, "they deserved to be a couple more than Harry and Ginny" and explained their controversial opinion on the friendship between the two from the books and how they led Dumbledore's Army together while the trio was absent.

虽然故事的主要焦点是金三角,但故事偶尔会切换到其他角色,如金妮和纳威。两人其实有一个很好的友谊,Reddit用户SherdyRavers说,“他们应该是一对,超过哈利和金妮”和解释他们的有争议的意见从两本书之间的友谊以及他们如何让邓不利多的军队一起在三人缺席。

 

As friends, they had a really good relationship because Ginny helped Neville become more confident and they were there for each other more than Harry ever was for Ginny一especially in the movies.

作为朋友,他们有一个很好的关系,因为金妮帮助纳威成为更有信心,他们对彼此有更多比哈利对金妮一尤其是在看电影。

 

4Chamber Of Secrets Was The Best Book Because Of Ginny

4因为金妮,《密室》成了最好的书

 

Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets had an intriguing plot with a great plot twist of Tom Riddle's diary being a Horcrux that only came into play later in the franchise. However, most fans on Reddit usually rank it lower than the other books and movies in the series. In a post about unpopular opinions, the Reddit user thefideliuscharm commented that they liked Chamber of Secrets "because it features Ginny and she was my favorite character."

《哈利·波特与密室》的情节很有趣,汤姆·里德尔的日记是一个魂器,这个魂器是后来才出现的。然而,Reddit上的大多数粉丝通常把它排在该系列的其他书籍和电影之后。在一篇关于不受欢迎观点的帖子中,Reddit用户thefideliuscharm评论道,他们喜欢《密室》,“因为里面有金妮,她是我最喜欢的角色。”

 

In the second book and movie, Ginny was the key antagonist due to being possessed by Tom Riddle through the journal. It was also one of the few times in Harry Potter that Ginny got more screentime, although the reveal that she was responsible for the opening of the chamber only came towards the end.

在第二部小说和电影中,金妮通过日记被汤姆·里德尔附身,成为了主要的敌人。这也是金妮在《哈利波特》中为数不多的几次出现在屏幕上的时间,尽管她对打开密室负责的消息直到最后才被披露。

 

3Ginny Shouldn't Have Been A Background Character

3金妮不应该成为背景人物

 

The Harry Potter series focused almost entirely on the Golden Trio with a majority of the attention going to Harry. As a result, most of the other characters didn't have much room for development, especially in the movies where a lot of things were cut out. The Redditor aps131997's unpopular opinion related to this was that "Ginny shouldn't have been a background character for more than half the series."

《哈利·波特》系列几乎全部聚焦在黄金三人组身上,大部分注意力都集中在哈利身上。结果是,大多数其他角色都没有太多的发展空间,尤其是在很多东西被剪掉的电影中。reddit用户aps131997对此不受欢迎的观点是:“金妮不应该在超过一半的剧集中成为背景人物。”

 

Considering that she ended up becoming the main character's love interest, giving her more screen time would have made that development a lot more acceptable and sensible. As it is, a lot of fans feel like the relationship didn't get the time it deserved for such a major development and most don't see the couple as a good match. However, Ginny didn't play much of a role in the major storylines, so bringing her to the forefront might have made her stick out awkwardly instead.

考虑到她最终成为主角的爱人,给她更多的屏幕时间会让这种发展更容易被接受和明智。事实上,很多粉丝觉得他们的关系没有得到应有的时间来发展,大多数人也不认为这对情侣是一对好搭档。然而,金妮在主要故事情节中并没有扮演太多角色,所以把她带到前线可能会让她尴尬地脱颖而出。

 

2Ginny & Hermione's Treatment Of Fleur Was Funny

2金妮和赫敏对待芙蓉的方式很有趣

 

When Fleur got engaged to Billy; Ginny, Hermione, and even Mrs.Weasley weren't happy about it. Ginny and Hermione said terrible things about her to Harry and Ron and taunted her behind her back. Most notably was Ginny calling Fleur "Phlegm." The Reddit user lemon-oreo posted an unpopular opinion that their feud was hilarious and said, "Ginny can be meanspirited, but she is insanely funny and one of my favorite characters."

芙蓉和比利订婚的时候;金妮、赫敏,甚至韦斯莱夫人都不高兴。金妮和赫敏对哈利和罗恩说了她的坏话,还在她背后奚落她。最引人注目的是金妮叫芙蓉“Phlegm”。Reddit用户lemon-oreo发布了一个不太受欢迎的观点,称他们的争吵非常搞笑,并说:“金妮可能很小气,但她非常有趣,是我最喜欢的角色之一。”

 

This opinion of their feud contrasts with most posts on Reddit about the girls' treatment of Fleur and how annoying and undeserved it was. Some of the taunts were set up as jokes, but beyond the surface the women's taunts and comments about Fleur felt a lot like bullying to most fans.

这种对她们不和的看法与Reddit上大多数关于女孩们如何对待芙蓉的帖子形成了鲜明对比,这些帖子是多么恼人,多么不值得。有些奚落是玩笑,但在表面之下,这些女人对芙蓉的奚落和评论对大多数粉丝来说更像是欺凌。

 

1Bonnie Wright Could Have Made Movie Ginny Better

1邦妮·赖特本可以把电影《金妮》拍得更好

 

Bonnie Wright played the part of Ginny since she was 9 years old and by the time the final movie was complete, she was 19. Most fans dislike Ginny's character because of how she doesn't get much development, but a few feel Wright was partly to blame for how she turned out. The Reddit user xthecollectorx said, "Bonnie could have put a bit more emotion, some feeling, something into the lines she did have."

邦妮·赖特从9岁开始扮演金妮,到最后一部电影完成时,她已经19岁了。大多数粉丝不喜欢金妮这个角色,因为她没有得到太多的发展,但也有一些人认为,她变成这样,部分要归咎于赖特。Reddit用户xcollectorx说:“邦妮本可以在她的台词中加入更多的情感和感觉。”

 

This view is understandable because while the script plays a big part in the making of a character, the actor's execution of the role determines how they're perceived. Also, having to execute a role that's based on a character in a book with more room to grow and express themselves can be a challenge, resulting in a performance that fans may not be pleased with.

这种观点是可以理解的,因为虽然剧本在塑造角色中扮演着重要的角色,但演员对角色的执行决定了他们如何被感知。此外,扮演一个基于书中有更多成长空间和表达空间的角色是一种挑战,可能会导致粉丝们不满意的表演。

 

全部评论